 ( Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn commissions from qualifying purchases at NO additional cost to the customer.)

Spread the love

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

I didn’t plan to fall in love with air fryer Totino’s pizza. It happened on a random weeknight when hunger hit, patience disappeared, and the oven felt like too much commitment. I tossed a Totino’s Party Pizza into the air fryer on a whim, fully expecting mediocrity. What I got instead? A shockingly crispy crust, bubbling cheese, and pepperoni edges that actually curled. I stood there, fork in hand, thinking, Why did no one tell me this sooner?

If Totino’s pizza brings back dorm-room memories or last-minute snack vibes, you’re not alone. But the air fryer turns that nostalgia into something better—faster, crispier, and weirdly satisfying. Below, I’ll share exactly how I make it, what I’ve learned the hard way, and the little tweaks that take it from “fine” to “wow, I’m making another.”

Why the Air Fryer Works So Well for Totino’s Pizza

I’ve cooked Totino’s every way imaginable. Oven? Fine, but slow. Microwave? Nope—unless soggy sadness counts as a texture. The air fryer hits the sweet spot.

Here’s why it works:

Rapid hot air crisps the thin crust evenly
Short cook time means no dried-out cheese
Direct heat curls pepperoni edges (aka flavor town)

Ever wonder why thin-crust pizza loves airflow? Because moisture escapes fast, and crispness shows up early. That’s the whole game here.

The Exact Totino’s Pizza I Use (And Where I Buy It)

I usually grab Totino’s Party Pizza – Pepperoni, because it’s classic and predictable in the best way. You can find it almost anywhere, but when I’m stocking up, I order it online.

Totino’s Party Pizza, Pepperoni (Frozen)
👉 https://amzn.to/4qpFjxv

I’ve tried the cheese and combination versions too. Pepperoni still wins IMO—more flavor, better crisping, fewer regrets.

Ingredients (Yes, It’s Short—and That’s the Point)

You don’t need much. That’s part of the charm.

Base Ingredients

1 Totino’s Party Pizza (frozen)
Nonstick spray (optional, but helpful)
Red pepper flakes (optional)
Dried oregano or Italian seasoning (optional)

That’s it. No thawing. No prep drama.

Step-by-Step: How I Cook Totino’s Pizza in the Air Fryer

Step 1: Preheat (Don’t Skip This)

I preheat my air fryer to 375°F for about 3 minutes. This step matters more than people admit. A hot basket equals instant crisp.

Step 2: Prep the Basket

I lightly spray the basket with nonstick spray. Some air fryers don’t need it, but I’ve learned the hard way that melted cheese loves to weld itself to metal.

Step 3: Place the Pizza

I place the pizza directly in the basket. If your air fryer runs small, cut the pizza in half. Scissors work better than knives here—FYI.

Step 4: Air Fry

Temperature: 375°F
Time: 6–8 minutes

I check at the 5-minute mark. Every air fryer has opinions, and mine runs hot.

Step 5: Cool Slightly (Yes, Really)

I let it sit for 1 minute. The cheese sets, the crust firms up, and I avoid molten-mouth regret.

How to Get the Crispiest Crust (Without Burning It)

This took trial, error, and one smoky kitchen moment.

My best tips:

Don’t cook at 400°F right away—it browns too fast
Use the middle rack/basket position if adjustable
Avoid foil; it blocks airflow
Cut into halves for even cooking in smaller baskets

Ever notice how thin pizza can go from perfect to charcoal in seconds? Stay close.

Toppings I Add When I’m Feeling Extra (But Not Fancy)

Totino’s works straight out of the box, but sometimes I tweak it.

Easy Add-Ons

Extra shredded mozzarella
Sliced jalapeños
Crushed red pepper
A drizzle of hot honey after cooking

I avoid piling on toppings. The crust stays thin, and overload ruins the crisp. Balance matters.

Air Fryer vs Oven vs Microwave (Real Talk)

I’ve tested all three more times than I’ll admit.

Air Fryer: Crispy, fast, best texture
Oven: Even, but slower and less crisp
Microwave: Soft, sad, emergency-only option

If you care about texture—and I do—the air fryer wins every time.

The Air Fryer I Use (And Trust)

I cook frozen pizza a lot. Like, a lot. The Cosori Pro II Air Fryer handles Totino’s perfectly.

👉 https://amzn.to/3YOoEHJ

Why I like it:

Consistent heat
Spacious basket
Easy cleanup (huge)

You don’t need this exact model, but a reliable air fryer makes repeat results easier.

Common Mistakes I’ve Made (So You Don’t Have To)

Cooking too hot → burnt edges, pale center
Walking away → pizza roulette
Stacking pizzas → uneven chaos

Frozen pizza needs attention. It’s low effort, not no effort.

Storage & Reheating (If You Have Leftovers)

Leftovers happen…sometimes.

Store in the fridge for up to 3 days
Reheat at 350°F for 3–4 minutes

I never microwave leftovers. The air fryer brings the crunch back. Trust me.

Why This Method Keeps Going Viral (And Deserves It)

People love air fryer Totino’s pizza because it:

Feels nostalgic
Cooks fast
Actually tastes better than expected

It’s comfort food without the wait. And honestly, that’s the whole appeal.

Save