 ( Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn commissions from qualifying purchases at NO additional cost to the customer.)

Spread the love

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

You know that one dessert people keep talking about long after the plates are cleared?
Yeah. This Black Forest Brownie Trifle is that dessert.

The first time I made it, I honestly just wanted to use up leftover brownies and a jar of cherries sitting in my pantry. I layered everything in a big glass bowl, crossed my fingers, and hoped for the best. Fast forward an hour, and people were scraping the sides like they’d lost all dignity. That’s when I knew I had something special.

This recipe blends fudgy brownies, juicy cherries, fluffy whipped cream, and rich chocolate flavor into one ridiculously indulgent dessert. It looks fancy. It tastes nostalgic. And best of all? It’s shockingly easy. Ever wondered how something this impressive can be this low stress? Same.

Let me show you exactly how I make it, plus all the little tweaks and tips I picked up from years of trial, error, and very honest taste testers.

Why Black Forest + Brownies Is a Power Move

Classic Black Forest cake already slaps. Chocolate, cherries, cream — what’s not to love? But brownies take it to another level.

Here’s why brownies win (IMO):

Denser texture that holds up under layers
Extra chocolate flavor without getting dry
Easier prep than baking cake layers

Brownies soak up cherry juices like champs without turning mushy. Cake sometimes collapses. Brownies stay confident. I respect that energy.

What Makes a Trifle Actually Good (Not Just Pretty)

I’ve eaten sad trifles. You probably have too. Dry cake. Too much cream. Zero balance.

A good trifle needs:

Texture contrast (soft + chewy + creamy)
Balanced sweetness
Even layering so every bite hits right

This recipe checks all those boxes without overthinking it. FYI, restraint matters here — especially with whipped cream.

The Ingredients (Nothing Complicated, Promise)

Here’s the lineup I use almost every time:

Brownie Layer

Homemade brownies or boxed mix
Fudgy > cakey (non-negotiable)

If I’m short on time, I grab Ghirardelli Double Chocolate Brownie Mix. It never lets me down.
👉 https://amzn.to/49xnsxo

Cherry Layer

Canned dark sweet cherries in syrup
OR cherry pie filling if you want it thicker

Pro tip: I lightly warm the cherries and add a splash of cherry juice over the brownies. Flavor boost, no effort.

Cream Layer

Heavy whipping cream
Powdered sugar
Vanilla extract

Skip store-bought whipped topping. Fresh cream tastes cleaner and less sweet.

Chocolate Boost (Optional but Encouraged)

Chocolate shavings
Chocolate chips
Chocolate curls

I use a vegetable peeler on a chocolate bar like a chaotic artist.

Let’s Talk Equipment (Because It Matters a Little)

A clear trifle bowl makes the layers pop. Presentation matters, even if you pretend it doesn’t.

I use this Anchor Hocking glass trifle bowl, and it’s worth every penny:
👉 https://amzn.to/4bwUksH

No trifle bowl? No problem. A large glass mixing bowl or individual jars work just fine.

Step-by-Step: How I Assemble This Without Overthinking It

Step 1: Bake and Cool the Brownies

Bake brownies according to recipe instructions. Let them cool fully. Warm brownies melt cream, and nobody wants soup.

Cut them into 1-inch chunks. Uneven pieces actually work better here.

Step 2: Prep the Cherries

Drain cherries slightly but keep some syrup. I like them juicy, not swimming.

If using cherry pie filling, break up the cherries gently with a spoon.

Step 3: Whip the Cream

Beat heavy cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla until soft peaks form.

Stop early. Overwhipped cream ruins lives. Ask me how I know :/

Layering the Trifle (The Fun Part)

Here’s how I build mine:

Brownie chunks (press lightly)
Spoon cherries + juice
Whipped cream
Repeat until the bowl fills

Finish with whipped cream and chocolate shavings on top.

That’s it. No ruler. No stress. Just vibes.

How Long Should It Chill? (Short Answer: At Least 2 Hours)

Chilling lets the flavors marry and the brownies soften slightly.

Minimum: 2 hours
Sweet spot: 4–6 hours
Overnight: Even better

Ever noticed how desserts taste better the next day? This one absolutely does.

Flavor Tweaks I Use Depending on the Crowd

I adjust this recipe all the time.

Adult Version

Add a splash of cherry liqueur or Kirsch to the cherries

Extra Chocolate Lover Version

Drizzle melted chocolate between layers

Lighter Version

Use Greek yogurt + whipped cream combo

Each version still tastes like a win.

Common Mistakes (Please Learn From Mine)

Let’s save you some heartbreak.

Using cakey brownies → too dry
Overwhipping cream → grainy texture
Too much cherry syrup → soggy layers
Rushing chill time → flavors don’t blend

Slow down. Dessert rewards patience.

Why This Dessert Always Wins at Parties

I bring this when I want zero leftovers.

People love it because:

It feels nostalgic but upgraded
It serves a crowd easily
It looks impressive without stress

Someone always asks for the recipe. Always.

Make-Ahead, Storage & Leftovers

This trifle holds up beautifully.

Make ahead: Up to 24 hours
Store covered: In the fridge
Lasts: 3 days (if it survives that long)

The brownies get softer, but in a good way.

Save