 ( Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn commissions from qualifying purchases at NO additional cost to the customer.)

Spread the love

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

I’ll just say it upfront: blood orange cake has personality. It’s not your shy lemon loaf or predictable vanilla sponge. This cake walks into the room wearing a deep pink blush, smells faintly floral, and somehow tastes bright, cozy, and a little dramatic all at once. The first time I baked it, I expected “nice citrus cake.” What I got instead was a dessert that made people stop mid-bite and say, “Wait… what is this?”

If you’ve ever stared at blood oranges in the grocery store—admired them, maybe snapped a photo, then walked away unsure what to do with them—this recipe is your moment. I’ve baked this cake more times than I can count, tweaked it across seasons, and served it to people who “don’t really like citrus desserts.” They always ask for seconds. Always.

So yeah, pull up a chair. Let’s talk blood orange cake, the kind you bake when you want something simple but special, impressive but not fussy.

Why Blood Orange Cake Feels Different (In the Best Way)

Blood oranges aren’t just oranges with a cool color. They bring a slightly berry-like flavor, less sharp than lemon, deeper than navel oranges. IMO, that’s why they shine in cakes.

Here’s what makes them perfect for baking:

Balanced acidity that doesn’t overwhelm
Natural sweetness with subtle bitterness
Gorgeous pink-red juice that tints the crumb

Ever wondered why blood orange cakes feel more “bakery-style” than basic citrus cakes? That complexity does the heavy lifting.

When Blood Oranges Are in Season (And What to Do If They’re Not)

In the U.S., blood oranges usually show up from December through April. I stock up during peak season and bake this cake nonstop.

If you can’t find them:

Use Cara Cara oranges for sweetness
Add 1–2 teaspoons blood orange extract for flavor depth
Accept that the color won’t be as dramatic (it happens)

The flavor still works. The cake still slaps. No stress.

Ingredients That Actually Matter Here

This cake looks simple, but a few choices make or break it.

Core Ingredients

Fresh blood oranges (zest + juice)
All-purpose flour
Eggs (room temp—this matters)
Granulated sugar
Neutral oil (I prefer avocado oil)
Baking powder
Salt
Vanilla extract

Optional but Worth It

Greek yogurt or sour cream (moisture insurance)
Powdered sugar (for glaze or dusting)

Amazon Ingredient Tool I Use Constantly:
Microplane Premium Zester – sharp enough to get zest without bitterness.

I’ve owned mine forever, and it still performs like day one.

The Mixing Method I Swear By

I don’t cream butter for this cake. Oil keeps it moist for days, which matters if you bake ahead (or snack slowly, like me).

Why Oil Works Better Than Butter Here

Keeps crumb tender even when cold
Lets citrus flavor shine
Zero waiting for butter to soften

Ever had a citrus cake dry out overnight? Oil fixes that problem.

Step-by-Step: How I Make My Blood Orange Cake

1. Prep the Pan and Oven

Preheat oven to 350°F
Grease a 9-inch round or loaf pan
Line bottom with parchment (trust me)

2. Zest First, Always

Zest your blood oranges before juicing them. You’ll need about:

2 tablespoons zest
½ cup fresh juice

The smell alone will convince you this cake is worth it.

3. Mix the Wet Ingredients

In a large bowl, whisk:

Sugar
Eggs
Oil
Yogurt or sour cream
Vanilla
Blood orange zest and juice

Whisk until smooth and glossy.

4. Add the Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, mix:

Flour
Baking powder
Salt

Fold gently into the wet mix. Don’t overthink it. Overmixing = dense cake.

5. Bake Until Just Right

Pour batter into pan and bake:

45–55 minutes for loaf
35–40 minutes for round pan

A toothpick should come out with a few moist crumbs, not clean.

Let’s Talk About the Glaze (Optional but Fantastic)

I sometimes skip glaze and dust with powdered sugar. Other days, I go all in.

Simple Blood Orange Glaze

1 cup powdered sugar
2–3 tablespoons blood orange juice

Whisk until thick but pourable. Drizzle generously.

Want extra drama? Add a pinch of salt. Sweet + salty always wins.

Texture, Flavor, and Why This Cake Gets Better Overnight

This cake improves after resting. The crumb tightens slightly, the citrus mellows, and the flavor deepens.

Day 1: bright and punchy
Day 2: balanced and bakery-level
Day 3: still moist (if it lasts that long)

FYI, I’ve eaten it straight from the fridge and loved it. No shame 🙂

Tools That Make This Cake Easier (And Why I Actually Use Them)

I don’t push gadgets unless they earn counter space.

Pan I Trust

USA Pan Loaf Pan – even browning, zero sticking.

Juicer That Saves My Hands

Zulay Metal Citrus Juicer – sturdy and mess-free.

Blood oranges aren’t huge, but they can fight back. This helps.

Common Mistakes I’ve Made (So You Don’t Have To)

Skipping zest = flat flavor
Using bottled juice = weird aftertaste
Overbaking = dry edges

Citrus cakes need attention near the end. Check early.

How This Compares to Other Citrus Cakes

I’ve baked lemon loaf, orange pound cake, grapefruit upside-down cake—you name it.

Blood orange cake wins because:

Less sharp than lemon
More complex than orange
More forgiving than grapefruit

It’s the “crowd-pleaser with personality” option.

Serving Ideas That Feel Fancy Without Effort

Slice with whipped cream
Add fresh berries
Serve with coffee or tea

Ever brought this to brunch? People assume it’s from a bakery.

Save